Southwest’s Identity Crisis: A Personal Take on Why It’s a Marketing Misstep

Southwest Airlines has always been different, and that’s exactly why people love it. No baggage fees? Awesome. Pick your own seat when you board? Perfect for travelers who don’t want to be locked into a seat assignment. These policies weren’t just perks—they were the heart of what made Southwest, well, Southwest.

So, when news started spreading that the airline might be ditching both of these at the same time, the internet understandably lost it. And from a marketing perspective, I can’t help but shake my head.

Taking Away What People Love About You Is Never a Good Idea

When you’re known for a couple of standout things, removing them all at once isn’t “ripping off a Band-Aid”—it’s erasing the very reason people liked you in the first place. Think about it: if you’ve built a loyal customer base around being the only airline that lets them check two bags for free, why on earth would you take that away?

People don’t just fly Southwest because of the price—they fly it because it’s easy. They don’t have to stress about picking a seat ahead of time. They don’t have to calculate how much extra their bags will cost. It’s a seamless, stress-free experience, and now that’s in jeopardy.

Stop Trying to Be Something You’re Not

One of the biggest mistakes a brand can make is abandoning what makes it unique just to try and compete with others. Southwest has always stood apart from the big legacy airlines like Delta and American. But now, it seems like they’re trying to be just like them—and customers aren’t happy about it.

Here’s the thing: people choose Southwest because it’s not like the others it has benefits that the bigger airlines could not compete with. When Southwest follows through with these changes, they may as well be just another airline in the mix—one that no longer has anything special to offer.

Consistency Builds Loyalty

Branding isn’t just about logos and colors. It’s about trust. People trust brands that are consistent, reliable, and predictable. When a company suddenly shifts direction, it makes customers feel uneasy.

Southwest has spent decades building a reputation as the airline that keeps things simple and traveler-friendly. If they take that away, they’re not just changing their policies—they’re breaking trust with the people who have supported them for years. And once that trust is gone, it’s incredibly hard to win back.

Need Help Defining (or Defending) Your Brand?

If you’re interested in strengthening your brand identity and digital presence, Samantha Trepeck | Marketing is here to help. We specialize in social media, website management, and influencer partnerships to ensure your brand stands out. Visit www.samanthatrepeck.com, email hello@samanthatrepeck.com, or schedule a complimentary consultation here. Let’s make sure your brand stays true to what makes it special.